Now Playing on JYB Films

Anatomy of the Comic Jihad


Movie File Host
YouTube YouTube
Putfile Putfile


Movie File Host
YouTube

The Meaning of Taqiyya







button02b
fpawbn
July 2007
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31        
$1 Shipping for 4 days, only at Overstock.com!
button
Recent Comments
•By KurtP
 at Aug 20, 1:01 AM about
 Sanctuary?
•By Elaine T
 at Aug 18, 11:27 PM about
 Sanctuary?
•By anon
 at Aug 18, 7:16 PM about
 Sanctuary?
•By tps
 at Aug 18, 6:39 PM about
 Sanctuary?
Archives

Content Staff
Technical Staff
credit where due
This site is still alive and kicking thanks to the generosity and talents of Alan M. Carroll (aka Annoying Old Guy). Without him, the JYB would still be suffering with Blogger's bad code and long-term archive loss.
Powered by
Hosted By
Anti-Junk: 7719 sources banned.

Sanctuary?

There’s this interesting case of an illegal immigrant claiming sanctuary in a Catholic Methodist Church. I don’t see what the problem is. Even a religious conservative like me knows that a priest, rabbi, or imam can’t unilaterally declare a structure off limits to the operation of state or federal law. The government agrees with me, but they’re scared to do anything about it:
Federal officials said there is no right to sanctuary in a church under U.S. law and nothing to prevent them from arresting her. But they would not say exactly what they planned to do, or when. The protest raised the spectacle of agents barging into a church and dragging her out.
That would be unfortunate and unpleasant, but it’s necessary. I don’t see why they should need anything more than a regular search warrant or arrest warrant to go in and get her. Which they ought to do before this becomes even more of a political disaster.

I wouldn’t expect a suspected terrorist to be able to take shelter from law enforcement in a mosque. Likewise I don’t expect anyone to claim sanctuary in a church. When Manuel Noriega did so in 1990, the United States refrained from going in to get him because he holed up and asked for sanctuary at the Vatican Embassy. Your average Chicago church does not enjoy the same protection.

UPDATE: Catholic, Methodist, whatever, same thing.

Seriously, though: don’t know where that slip came from—perhaps because every discussion of sanctuary I’ve seen has involved a Catholic church. Thanks to alert reader Elaine T.

Post to del.icio.us

Posted by SeeDubya on August 18, 2006 4:42 PM
Trackbacks: View (0)Ping
Comments

I could be wrong but I think in the Catholic tradition ‘sanctuary’ doesn’t apply to the whole building. Just to the area right around the alter. So that means the police can come in but it might look bad if they do.

I do like the background at Wiki about how it was handled in the Middle Ages:

Church sanctuaries were regulated by common law. An asylum seeker was to confess his sins, surrender his weapons, and be placed under the supervision of the head of the church or abbey where he had fled. He then had forty days to make one of two choices: surrender to secular authorities and stand trial for the crimes against him, or confess his guilt and be sent into exile (abjure the realm), by the shortest route and never return without the king’s permission. Anyone who did come back could be executed by the law and/or excommunicated by the Church.

Posted by tps on August 18, 2006 6:39 PM

michael graham recommended investigating social security violations in the neighborhood, and rounding up illegals at their places of employment for deportation.

once enough heat is applied, la migra won’t have to set foot on the church premises to get her to leave.

it’ll never happen though.

Posted by anon on August 18, 2006 7:16 PM

/nit pick/ It’s a Methodist Church, not a Catholic one.

And also is probably basicly a publicity stunt.

Posted by Elaine T on August 18, 2006 11:27 PM

HMMMMMmmmmmmmmmm…Federal Government + Church+ force,,,,,,Wy do I keep reminding myself of WACO???

I don’t know why I’d equate that to what’s happening in Ill.; since the ones in Waco were law abiding citizens,

Post a comment